New California Bill (AB 473) Threatens to Gut “Truth in Labeling” Law (SB 343) 

Update: April 11, 2025
In a win for the people of California: the author of California bill AB 473 informed stakeholders that her office was “not moving forward with AB 473” on April 10, 2025. A letter led by Plastic Pollution Coalition and signed by more than 150 NGOs and businesses played a key role in showing policymakers the dangers of passing AB 473, which would have gutted the “Truth in Labeling” law SB 343.


On February 27, 150 environmental organizations and businesses sent a letter to California Assembly Natural Resources Committee Chair Isaac Bryan and California Gov. Gavin Newsom, opposing the newly introduced Assembly Bill 473 Environmental advertising: recyclability (AB 473), which would gut California’s existing “Truth in Labeling” Law (SB 343) by allowing false recyclability claims to be applied to all single-use plastic items. The AB 473 opposition letter urges that the existing law, SB 343, be fully implemented as intended to identify what actually gets recycled in the state to prevent deceptive claims around the recycling of plastics. The bill is expected to be heard in committee this week. 

Meanwhile, plastic industry influence continues to undermine the state’s existing plastic reduction policies, despite continued opposition from NGOs and businesses. On Friday, March 7, California Gov. Gavin Newsom walked back on existing plastic pollution regulations by calling for a reworking of the state’s landmark extended producer responsibility law, SB 54, which passed in 2022 and would have limited the amount of single-use plastics distributed and sold in California. Plastic Pollution Coalition and other Break Free From Plastic movement organizations condemned policymakers’ betrayal of voters in compromising with the plastics industry in California, as well as the state’s failure to implement SB 54. The organizations remain committed to reevaluating all possible avenues, including reviving the initiative to let voters decide.

These developments are a strong example of how continued plastic industry influence on politics is delaying and distracting from the implementation of effective plastic pollution legislation.

A bill like the proposed AB 473 only serves to delay and distract from the fact that plastic is not made to be recycled. It is unacceptable that implementation of SB 54 is delayed by industry lobbyists tactics, and the silence on our statewide polystyrene ban is deafening. It is past time for California to start implementing our existing laws on plastic that actually solve the problem and not perpetuate it.

— Jackie Nuñez, Advocacy and Engagement Manager, Plastic Pollution Coalition, and Founder of The Last Plastic Straw

AB 473 Would Allow for False Recyclability Claims

The new bill, AB 473, authored by California Assembly Member Lori Wilson, was quietly introduced in the Assembly on February 6, 2025. AB 473 would allow for false recyclability claims to be applied to all single-use plastic items, including plastic cups, cutlery, lids, multi-layer pouches, plastic bags, plates, trays, and wrappers. These and all single-use plastic items are not designed to be recycled, nor have they ever been recycled in California.

Assemblymember Lori Wilson of AB 473 claims that a “technical fix” is needed to the existing California labeling law (SB 343) to “improve it.” This is inaccurate. The intent of AB 473 is to delay enforcement and weaken California’s Truth in Labeling law and to allow plastic that cannot actually be recycled to have a recyclable label. This deceptive move is designed to perpetuate the plastic industry’s myth that recycling plastic solves plastic pollution, and thus supports more plastic production—when in reality, to solve plastic pollution, we need to produce less plastic. The opposition groups emphasized that SB343, passed in 2021, requires no fixes and must be implemented to the letter of the law.

The opposition groups identified some of the many reasons why AB 473 should NOT be adopted, including:  

  • It is counterproductive to California’s goal of reducing plastic pollution and waste. 
  • There are serious worker safety issues in sorting facilities, as plastics increase workers’ exposures to plastic chemicals and particles and put workers at greater risk of harm from plastic-fueled dangers like fires and explosions.
  • It causes increased costs to consumers paying for curbside recycling services for the collection of unrecyclable single-use plastic items, which contaminate potentially recyclable items.

AB 473 is designed to override California’s groundbreaking SB 343 “Truth in Labeling” Law, which requires product companies to earn recyclable labels for their products. For a product to be labeled recyclable it must be: (1) collected, (2) sorted, (3) reprocessed into new materials, and (4) pass Basel Plastic Waste Amendment contamination limits; AB 473 would change this because producers would no longer have to adhere to those requirements. Instead, the proposed bill grants producers an extension, until 2032, to prove compliance.

We must require truth when it comes to recycling labels. AB 473 will undermine California’s pollution reduction goals by allowing deceptive labeling on any and all plastic.

–– Susan Keefe, Director, Southern California, Beyond Plastics

Efforts to end plastic pollution are not only about labels, but about reducing plastic production: the source of plastic pollution. However, single-use plastic production will not be reduced and will instead be disincentivized if such items are legally claimed and falsely labeled to be recyclable. More information can be found in the OPPOSE letter authored by Basel Action Network, Beyond Plastics, The Last Beach Cleanup, and Plastic Pollution Coalition.

California Plastic Reduction Law (SB 54) Still Not Implemented

The Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act SB 54 (Allen, 2022) is intended to force companies making plastic (“producers”) into funding the recycling of their products. SB 54 has a 10-year implementation schedule, meaning that producers should not be able to label their products as recyclable until the products can actually be recycled, per the existing requirements in SB 343—the “Truth in Labeling” law. Producers must be required to invest in recycling facilities and earn a recyclable label on their products by proving their recyclability. As detailed by California Department of Justice in People vs. ExxonMobil, the plastics industry has a 50-year history of deceiving consumers on the recyclability of plastic products, including use of the chasing arrows label on products that have never been recycled.

When the SB 54 draft comment period opened in the summer of 2024, Plastic Pollution Coalition and eight other organizations shared concerns over the legislation’s many vague definitions and focus on recycling target rates rather than source reduction, as well as their deep disappointment to learn that the sole Producer Responsibility Organization approved was the Circular Action Alliance that was composed of board members from some of the largest plastic polluters.

We knew then that plastic producers were not acting in good faith, nor did they really intend to work with the State of California to solve the plastic pollution crisis. Rather, they were only there to ensure they could continue actively undermining and delaying the implementation of California’s plastic reduction laws. This is the fox guarding the hen house. Californians want an end to the plastic pollution crisis, and have voted to do so. It is time to let the voters have a direct say in regulations that hold plastic producers accountable for their pollution. The plastics industry has proven time and again that they are incapable of self regulation and will only continue business as usual at the expense of current and future generations. If the leaders won’t lead, the people will.

— Dianna Cohen Co-Founder & CEO Plastic Pollution Coalition

The continued acceptance of mislabeled products and distraction tactics are the mark of industry lobbyists’ delay tactics, and a troublesome trend in California. As reported in the LA Times “The former director of CalRecycle [the state of California’s recycling agency]—who oversaw, wrote and promoted the single-use plastic legislation known as SB 54—is now the executive director of the Circular Action Alliance, a coalition of plastic and packaging companies determined to delay, if not derail, the law.”

As of January 1, 2025, polystyrene foam under SB 54 is illegal to sell, distribute, or import into California; yet, the Governor who signed it into law, and CalRecycle—the agency tasked to implement and enforce those laws—had made no real announcements, leaving many state residents and business left unaware that it is now illegal. With an ethics violation lodged against the former CalRecycle director and increasing pressure from industry lobbyists towards the governor’s office to delay implementation, Plastic Pollution Coalition along with many environmental groups submitted a letter to the governor’s office urging the implementation of SB 54 by the March 8, 2025, deadline.

Take Action 

California may lead in passing strong laws to reduce plastic pollution, but those in charge to enforce those laws have fallen behind. Plastics were never designed to be recycled, and policymakers should be working to end greenwashing, not make concessions to plastic producers that help perpetuate harmful narratives enabling continued plastic pollution.

You may help by calling Governor Newsom at (916) 445-2841 and selecting option 6 to speak to a representative, and tell them: “we want the Governor to urge the Assembly Natural Resources Committee to reject the passage of AB 473, which will undermine California’s existing ‘Truth In Labeling’ Law, and to move forward SB 54 regulations without delay so that California can continue to be a global leader in addressing plastic pollution.”

27

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Donate

To Stop Plastic Pollution